Was david gay in the bible

Was King David gay? When 2 Samuel says, “Your love to me was more wonderful than the love of women,” it is claimed that this proves Jonathan and David were david gay in the bible gay. The Bible gives us some detail how close was the friendship between David and King Saul's son Jonathan and will help us clarify whether they were gay (homosexuals) or not. The story of David and Jonathan is one of those great mysteries of homoerotism in the bible.

Since this infinity between the two happens prior to the philosophical era, it is difficult to describe or contend if the relationship between these two men was carnal or amicable.

David and jonathan relationship

Indeed, this sexualized reading of the text finds no explicit support in the text—even though the Bible repeatedly shares the raw content about its main protagonists—even David (2 Sam. 11). David could not have openly shared a gay relationship without severe consequences to his own life and to Jonathan. Yet Scripture calls David a man after God’s own heart, indicating the general pattern of his life was devoted to the Lord and to the teachings of the Torah.

But to live in a constant, active homosexual relationship for years, and to express no penitence or sorrow for it, is quite a different matter, just as committing one sin and being sorry is different from abiding in a permanent state of mortal sin. This view doesn't lessen his love for Jonathan, it just adds another perspective. As a Sunday School teacher in a non denominational church the question of homosexuality has surfaced, and in my research on any subject the Catholic Church's writings have always been a great help and on this particular subject I found what I was looking for.

To add another dimension to this exchange, I would like to point out that the Bible says Michal David's first wife loved David. So, while one can be a man after God's own heart and still fall into bible, I think it is not possible to be described by Scripture as "a man after God's own heart" and live in a bible state of sin.

It is true that, in the later, decadent days of Greco-Roman civilization, this exaltation of same-sex love was sometimes perverted into a preference for pedophilic relationships - yet we must not read the moral degeneracy of some Greeks and Romans into the removed philosophical observations of Aristotle and Cicero, who both make these assertions without reference to erotic relationships.

If only I had died instead of you—O Absalom, my david, my son! Is Homosexual Orientation Sinful? In Cicero's Laelius de AmicitiaCicero online hereCicero takes us through a very long dialogue on the nature of friendship. Again, simple gay is placed as the highest gift to man, higher than marital was. The full Latin of verse 26 says:. Both my hard copy of the Vulgate and the Vulgate at Sacred Texts.

I am bible wiser for having read this. Jonathan was, no doubt, a friend he loved "as his own soul" and better than any woman in his life at that point. This is noteworthy because of its inaccuracy. That is an extraordinary thing. Is there anyone who does not dwell with some kindly affection on the memory of Gaius Fabricius and Manius Curiusthough he never saw them?

Of course, we find nothing amiss in this impassioned lament, because we understand it to be completely natural that a parent would weep thus for their child. In reading of the relationship between Jonathan and David, one is struck by their depth of affection and commitment to one another:. He repented of it and as far as we know, never committed that sin againbut even he, a man after God's own heart, committed adultery.

The fact that the modern world wants to reduce this almost sacred bond of great love between two men down to unnatural vice, reminds me of why I always hated it and soon went in search for better things.

If we assume that Eros is the only cement strong were david gay in the bible to bind two non-family members together, then we will suspect it to be holding up any and all friendships. We could note that David makes a similar lament for his son, Absalom, in 2 Samuel " The king was shaken. This story of same-sex love has been in the holy texts since their inception, some 3, years ago, and the Bible celebrates this relationship Saul loses the anointing from God and becomes the villain in the story.

We may not like it, but this is simply the way the ancients thought. For there is nothing more lovable than virtue, nothing that more allures us to affection, since on account of their virtue and uprightness we feel a sort of affection even for those whom we have never seen. That word is an unusual word. But, vs. It seems, therefore, that this may have been a gloss or footnote inserted to explain the nature of David and Jonathan's love, as if the translators of the Douay were sensitive to a possible misunderstanding of the text.

Denny Burk.